Western Australia’s resource extraction industries, particularly mining and metals, have historically been a strong pillar of the global economy. However, for investors navigating this sector, the picture can be clouded by conflicting forecasts. Concerns like “pricing bubbles,” potential recessions, and resource scarcity coexist with predictions of high demand.
The Challenge of Cyclicality
The inherent cyclical nature of the mining and metals industry makes traditional business valuation methods more complex. Two key cycles play a significant role:
- Commodity Price Cycle: The price of the specific resource being extracted experiences boom and bust periods. This impacts all producers of that commodity, with an upswing benefiting all players and a downturn creating burdens even for the strongest companies.
- Economic Cycle: The broader economic climate also plays a role. Extended periods of low economic activity can dampen demand for resources, further impacting profitability.
This dependence on external factors, over which companies have limited control, is a significant risk for investors.
Long Lead Times
Adding another layer of complexity are the industry’s long lead times. Bringing new production capacity online can take 5-10 years or more due to factors like equipment procurement and mine development processes. This means projects often begin operations years after their initial conception, exposing them to the possibility of a changing market landscape by the time they are ready to produce.
Tailored Valuation Approaches for Different Stages
Due to these unique characteristics, valuing resource extraction companies requires a nuanced approach. There are three main categories of mineral properties, each with its own valuation methods:
- Exploration Properties: These properties have yet to demonstrate the existence of a viable mineral deposit. Their value lies solely in their potential for future discovery. Since only a small percentage of exploration properties ultimately become producing mines, their valuation is highly speculative.
- Development Properties: These properties have confirmed viable deposits, often supported by feasibility studies, but are not yet operational. With more reliable information available, such as resource estimates, production plans, and cost projections, a degree of confidence can be placed on valuations using discounted cash flow methods.
- Production Properties: These are active mines generating revenue. Their valuation can leverage traditional methods with greater accuracy due to established production data and cash flow.
Business valuation in WA’s resource extraction industry requires a careful balancing act. Understanding the cyclical nature of the market, the long lead times involved, and the different stages of development for mineral properties are all crucial for making informed investment decisions. By acknowledging these complexities and utilizing appropriate valuation methods, investors can navigate the uncertainties inherent in this sector and make sound financial choices.
Read our other blog:
How many times profit is a business worth? Is it 5?
Backed Valuation Multiples by Industries
See other resources:
Insight Advisory Group
